Tor
What Tor Is
How onion routing works, what it guarantees, what it does not, and the misconceptions that cause harm.
Tor routes traffic through a volunteer-run network of relays so that no single party can see both who is connecting and what they are connecting to. That is a narrower and more specific claim than most descriptions of it, and understanding the difference is the point of this page.
How a circuit is built
- Your client asks a guard relay, which is a relay it has agreed to use for a period of time. The guard learns your IP address. Nothing else does.
- The guard contacts a middle relay, which learns the guard but not your address.
- The middle contacts an exit relay, which completes the connection. Only the exit sees your destination, and only if you have not also used an onion service.
- The reply travels back along the same path.
Traffic between the relays is layered — “onion” — so that each relay knows only its own neighbour in either direction. The circuit is normally rebuilt every few minutes, so no single relay observes more than a small amount of your traffic.
What Tor protects against
- Local network monitoring. A café or workplace network sees an encrypted connection to a relay, not the destination.
- Service providers. The destination sees a connection from an exit relay.
- Passive network observers who cannot see inside the circuit.
- Tracking and fingerprinting when using Tor Browser, which standardises the fingerprint so you are indistinguishable from other users.
What Tor does not protect against
Onion services
An .onion address resolves within the network, so there is no exit relay and no DNS
lookup. The service learns the client’s exit from the rendezvous point, not from a
connection to a known address, and users authenticate to the service with a client
certificate. This is a meaningfully stronger design than a web page reached through a
circuit.
Common misconceptions
| Claim | Reality |
|---|---|
| “Tor is slow because it is weak” | Circuits, and guard and exit relay capacity relative to user count. See metrics. |
| “Tor is anonymous, full stop” | It hides your network location and destination from each other. Accounts and behaviour still identify you. |
| “The Tor Project can read messages” | It cannot, and cannot be compelled to. The Double Ratchet design has no server-side plaintext. |
| “A VPN plus Tor is automatically better” | It depends entirely on who you were trying to hide from. See what VPNs do and do not. |
| “There is a backdoor” | No such claim should be repeated without a document. Anyone asserting one should be asked for the primary source. |
Sources
- About Tor — the protocol as its designers describe it.
- Tor Metrics — current, verifiable network figures.
- Tor: The Second-Generation Onion Router — the design paper’s account of entry, middle and exit roles. (The paper predates the “guard” terminology and uses “entry”.)
- EFF: Tor and HTTPS — why the two are complementary rather than substitutes.
Topics
Sources
- Tor Project: About Tor Accessed
- Tor Metrics The authoritative source for relay and network counts, rather than a rounded figure quoted elsewhere. Accessed
- Tor: The Second-Generation Onion Router The separately titled "Tor Relay System" page cited previously is not present in the Tor Project design-paper archive index; this is the design paper by the same authors, and the one that sets out circuit construction and the first, middle and last relay roles. It predates the "guard" terminology, so it says "entry" where current Tor documentation says "guard". Accessed
- How HTTPS and Tor Work Together to Protect Your Anonymity and Privacy The Surveillance Self-Defense module "Tor and HTTPS" was moved off ssd.eff.org onto this standalone EFF microsite. It still resolves from https://www.eff.org/pages/tor-and-https, and the current SSD guide "How to - Use Tor" links to it as further reading. Accessed
Related guides
-
Guide Intermediate
Tor Browser and Searching on Tor (Guide)
The configuration that makes Tor usable, why the fingerprint is identical for everyone, and how onion search works.
-
Guide Intermediate
What VPNs Do and Do Not Do (Guide)
The single change a VPN makes, the trust it transfers rather than removes, and how to read a provider claim.
-
Guide Introductory
Metadata Explained (Guide)
A worked primer on data about data: what leaks even with perfect encryption, and the measures that actually reduce it.
-
Guide Intermediate
Browser Fingerprinting (Guide)
How a device gets identified from the shape of its requests, what resists it, and what a fingerprint is worth.